A New Jersey woman is suing JetBlue after she claims a “frozen solid” ice cream sandwich caused her to fracture a front tooth. Kiara Quinonez says she was served a Nightingale strawberry shortcake ice cream sandwich during a flight from New York to Paris and was caught off guard by its subzero temperature. The lawsuit argues she wasn’t warned about the icy dessert’s “dangerously cold” state, resulting in her needing immediate dental treatment upon landing in Paris, including an extraction and implant.

This isn’t JetBlue’s first brush with dessert-related lawsuits; another passenger previously sued for severe burns from spilled hot tea! It seems flying with JetBlue comes with the risk of either dental emergencies or scalding hot surprises—pick your poison!